Join Date: 06 February 2016

Posts: 2838

Posted on 18 July 2017 - 07:07 PM

Ads_ wrote

GodShots wrote...

PM Link

Robiswell Members

Join Date: 29 November 2015

Posts: 4114

Posted on 18 July 2017 - 09:27 PM

-1

I'm going to use an example to explain my reasoning.

Let's say you're gold v in build. You lost 1000 points to a cheater and got demoted to silver 1. Now let's say then you got yourself from silver 1 to emerald 1 and then later got rewarded 1000 points and is promoted to diamond V.

Do you now see how this is wrong?

PM Link

GodShots Members

Join Date: 06 August 2015

Posts: 14

Posted on 08 August 2017 - 12:13 PM

SirDeqdly wrote

-1 easily abuse-able. I could farm a someone and then get a high rank and when he gets banned I'll double the rank I was.

No, you wouldn't gain points as if you won the match, you get the points you lost back. It wouldn't be like you lost, and that lost turned into a win. It would be like that match never happened in the first place.

PM Link

newname1234 Members

Join Date: 13 March 2016

Posts: 226

Posted on 08 August 2017 - 12:15 PM

-1

PM Link

MaccariTA Members

Join Date: 27 April 2016

Posts: 449

Posted on 08 August 2017 - 12:21 PM

Purped wrote

There is too much room for error in this idea. The amount of false bans would annoying for some people and lead to many points being falsely gained. If this idea were to be implemented I'd say to include mod bans as well because those can happen quite often and be false as well. Plus like people said, just work and get the points back, if you go to one spot originally you can probably do it again.

PM Link

Tvjuli Premium

Positions:

- Retired Staff

Join Date: 22 December 2015

Posts: 1202

Last edited on 08 August 2017 - 04:06 PM by Tvjuli

The idea of the elo system (thinking on s15) is that one player gains points and the other one losses them, If you add elo out of nowere you are inflating the pool and ruining the system in a way (this is a bit more complicated but idk how to explain it)
Also you would gain more points since you have lower elo from next fights, wich would be infair if you got the points back

With reseting the stats of all cheaters I would be happy, I cheked the top 100 of SA in BuildUHC and 56 of those are banned….

PM Link

Robiswell Members

Join Date: 29 November 2015

Posts: 4114

Posted on 08 August 2017 - 08:36 PM

Purped wrote

There is too much room for error in this idea. The amount of false bans would annoying for some people and lead to many points being falsely gained. If this idea were to be implemented I'd say to include mod bans as well because those can happen quite often and be false as well. Plus like people said, just work and get the points back, if you go to one spot originally you can probably do it again.

I was going to type a bible but this sums it up

PM Link

luizlqx_ Members

Join Date: 03 April 2017

Posts: 94

Posted on 09 August 2017 - 04:16 PM

+1

PM Link